Enigmerra
Possible score
Theft 3 attempts

The Torch of the Crown

A bitter morning has settled over Realm of the Crown: something precious has vanished without a trace. The loss is not only in gold: it is in the trust that shattered along with the lock. The testimonies keep returning to the same names: Chamberlain Iorgu, Luca the Squire, Sir Bogdan de Fag and Costache the Toll-Keeper. The testimonies cling to certain hours: "at dawn", "after matins", "at noon" and "at dusk". Few files have tested so many investigators; untangle the threads, catch the lie, and pronounce your verdict.

From the Chancellery archive

The torch of the crown is not a torch. It is the name the court gives to the thing without which a coronation cannot be held — and it was precisely that which was missing when it was needed. The Chancellery opened the dossier within the hour.

The four suspects all stand on the steps of power, but at different heights. Chamberlain Iorgu orders who enters the palace. Costache the Toll-Keeper rules over what enters the realm. Sir Bogdan de Fag has a sword and a voice. Luca the Squire has neither sword of his own nor voice — he has only access, which in a theft is sometimes quite enough.

The places descend from the guild forge to the old dungeon, by way of the customs cellar and the Golden Boar inn. The objects are all precious: a stained parchment, an amber necklace, a silver-clad icon and the bishop's chalice.

Tier III. There are testimonies, so there is a lie. Test them one by one against the grid: the one that will not sit with the rest is the signature you are after.

Suspects

Locations

Objects

Moments

Open the Grid (below) to solve the case, with the testimonies at hand.

The deduction grid

Touch a cell: blank → ✗ (excluded) → ✓ (certain) → blank. Each pair of categories meets exactly once.

SUSPECTS LOCATIONS OBJECTS
Chamberlain Iorgu Luca the Squire Sir Bogdan de Fag Costache the Toll-Keeper the guild forge the customs cellar the Golden Boar inn the old dungeon the stained parchment the amber necklace the silver-clad icon the bishop's chalice
MOMENTS at dawn
after matins
at noon
at dusk
OBJECTS the stained parchment
the amber necklace
the silver-clad icon
the bishop's chalice
LOCATIONS the guild forge
the customs cellar
the Golden Boar inn
the old dungeon

Verdict

The culprit always lies; everyone else tells the truth.

Clues & testimonies
  1. About the culprit, the Chancellery knows one thing for certain: the culprit was at the old dungeon.
  2. The chronicler notes drily: the stained parchment matches that hour: at dusk, whatever the court may say.
  3. A maid whispered it at confession: the guild forge and the silver-clad icon go together.
  4. The customs register is clear: the Golden Boar inn does not match that hour: at dawn.
  5. The scouts confirm it: at suspects, the paths of the bishop's chalice and the customs cellar diverge.
  6. Chamberlain Iorgu raises their right hand and says: "I was there at noon".
  7. Before the investigator, Luca the Squire firmly repeats: "I was at the guild forge".
  8. The gate guard swears: the silver-clad icon matches that hour: after matins.
  9. The bell-ringer remembers well: the suspect with green eyes came earlier than Costache the Toll-Keeper.
  10. At the Chancellery, Costache the Toll-Keeper maintains: "I was there at dawn".

The archivist's clues

Ask for them in turn — each revealed clue lowers your score by 10%.